Place Categories: American and Restaurants & Bars.
Related Listing
2 reviews
Place Your Review
Report this?
The Insider's Guide to the Hamptons and North Fork
- Welcome , Guest
- Sign In
Bay Burger
Address : 1742 Sag Harbor Tpke, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
Listing Title : Bay Burger
Category :Place Categories: American and Restaurants & Bars.
Phone : 631 899 3915
/5 based on 2 user reviews.
Bay Burger
Oliver Peterson, Dec 07, 2012 - Bay Burger
4/5
Great burgers with homemade buns. Also love the chicken and the veggie burgers. Inexpensive, but the bill adds up as you add extras, tater tots, a drink, etc. A really good neighborhood joint in Sag Harbor. Fun stuff for kids too.
Olivia White, Dec 11, 2012 - Bay Burger
2/5
The fries and tots are the best, the burgers are good but a tad on the charcoal tasting side. Some people like this – not my favorite but for the price and throw in a milk shake with Joe and Liza’s ice cream (even though it’s ridiculously expensive) and you end up with a good meal at a OK price for the Hamptons and you’ve had it in a fun spot. This used to be Whaler Burger and they still have the big Whale up on the wall – which is fun. Check out the Sag Harbor Farmers Market here in the Fall and early winter.